Shay Carl Butler is a comedian, actor, and entrepreneur living in Idaho. He is a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. He was born on 5 March 1980, and he is the creator of the "Shaytards. His YouTube channels Shaycarl," ShayLoss, iphoneTARD, and Shaytards are some of the most popular on YouTube. Shay joined with other YouTube celebrities and started Maker Studios, a YouTube production company. Through Maker Studios, Shay and other YouTube celebrities such as Kassem G and Lisa Nova collaborate on videos for the studio's in-house YouTube channel, The Station. In addition to The Station, the studio manages many of the top YouTube channels.
Shay has had over twenty jobs throughout his life, including owning a custom granite countertop company called Rock Tops. In his free time, Shay became enthralled with watching videos. He said that the first time he came on YouTube, he was shocked to realize he had watched until dawn. Shay started his own YouTube channel called "Shaycarl" (a combination of his first and middle name) and added his first video "Fun with Helium and Passing Out" on 16 August 2007. Shortly after starting the channel, he took a job as a disc jockey at a local radio station, Z103.
On 27 November 2007, Shay entered a contest sponsored by popular YouTube vlogger, Philip DeFranco. Shay not only won a tee-shirt but the endorsement of DeFranco. The popularity of the "Shaycarl" channel shot up overnight. Today, the channel has garnered more than 1.6 million subscribers and it continues to rank high on several of YouTube's "Most Subscribed" lists. In April 2008, Shay began broadcasting live from his job at Z103 on BlogTV. During his time on BlogTV, the fans of the videos began calling themselves "ShayTards" after a video Shay made claiming his love for unitards. That evolved into fans calling themselves the "Shaytard Rebellionites."
On 2 October 2008, Shay started a new channel, "Shaytards." It was initially a channel where his viewers could join him in trying to lose weight by supporting each other. Frequent appearances by his family members made for fun and exciting content that viewers asked to see more often. On 2 March 2009, Shay and his family decided to make a video for each day of his 29th year starting on his March 5th birthday. Because Shay is a natural comedian, and his wife and children all possess a flair for comedy, the daily vlogs were a hit with fans. For safety, they decided to keep their last name private and to adopt stage names for their family. Taking a cue from his fans, the family was given "Tard" names after the Shaytard channel and ShayTard Rebellionites. Shay's wife, "Katilette"(also a stage name) became known as "MommyTard." His oldest son as "SonTard," his oldest daughter "PrincessTard" and youngest daughter "BabyTard." Shay and Katilette's extended families often appear in the vlogs. Soon, Shay was collaborating with other YouTube vloggers, going to YouTube gatherings and becoming friends with others in the YouTube community. Over time, all of Shay's channels became YouTube Partner channels. The YouTube Partner Program allows channels to generate revenue from views. Many YouTube Partners, including Shay, have been able to replace their former income and work full-time on their videos and other related ventures while maintaining or even exceeding their former income. Partners also benefit from ads on their channels and videos and sometimes, product placement.
During the first year of the "Shaytards", Shay and his family moved to California to collaborate with other YouTuber's and start a multimedia entertainment and production company called Maker Studios. They began a new YouTube channel, "The Station" which features comedy videos starring many of YouTube's famous vloggers. "The Station" and it's offshoot channels became an overnight hit. While the new business was thriving, Shay and Katilette decided to return home to Idaho for the sake of the family. Although Shay flies to LA and other locations to work once or twice a month, the main focus of the channel is filming their daily lives. In June of 2010, their fourth child, known as "RockTard" was born. The vlog surrounding the birth of the child is one of the most popular and most viewed among the "Shaytards" videos with over 21 million views. In January 2011, Shay was cast in his first television role, playing a security guard on the ABC program, No Ordinary Family.
Shay is the oldest brother to three siblings, Casey, Carlie and Logan. Along with his parents and his in-laws, they often make appearances in his vlogs. His youngest brother Logan has his own YouTube channel, LoganMcKay55. Shay served a mission for The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, in the West Indies. When he returned he married a fellow member of the Church, "Katilette" on 3 January 2003 in the Idaho Falls Idaho Temple. The couple now has four children.
The "Shaytards" have shown their love for the gospel in many videos and provided a wonderful example of a Latter-day Saint family for viewers who may not know anything about the Church. Fans are often shocked to find out that the family is Mormon. While they have never made the Church the sole focus of their videos, they have done several videos where the family is preparing for or just returning from Church, doing service as a family, or just spending time together. "What Do We Feed Our Spirits" is a video of a Family Home Evening lesson done for the children. The vlog sparked a large number of comments asking about the religion of the family.
Adhering to an important tenet of The Church Of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Shay often talks about the dangers of getting into and living with debt. In a joyous and exciting video "We're Debt Free!", Shay and the family call The Dave Ramsey Show to tell their story of paying off their debt. Recently, the family has started "One Take Sundays," choosing not to edit vlogs on the Sabbath.
The Shaytards, along with other successful Latter-day Saint YouTubers were invited to participate in the December 2014 video created along with the effort to claim the Guinness Book of World Records’ title for largest live Nativity, which was achieved with over one thousand participants. Shay Carl portrayed one of the wise men. The final video premiered on The Piano Guys’ YouTube channel and to date has been viewed more than 15 times. Along with the live Nativity, The Piano Guys, David Archuleta, Peter Hollens, and the Mormon Tabernacle Choir performed “Angels from the Realms of Glory.” Shay said he became involved "mostly for my kids. It's clichéd to say 'it's about Jesus; it's not about all the commercialism, but I wanted to do something to actually show them that."
Leaders of the Church of Jesus Christ, such as M. Russell Ballard and David A. Bednar— both members of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles — have encouraged members of the Church to share the gospel through social media. 
Early in 2015, the Deseret News reported the stories of two families — one from England and one from Netherlands — who were drawn to the happiness, examples, and testimonies of Shay and Colette Butler, were taught by the missionaries and joined the Church. 
As of the end of 2021, Shay Carl is still producing YouTube videos.
- Shay Carl's Facebook Page
- Shay Carl's YouTube Channel
- Shay Carl's Instagram Page
- YouTuber Shay Carl Butler Deletes Twitter, Privates Instagram After Stopping Shaytards Vlogs